Taking a Step Down in Your Late 50s: A Choice or No Choice at All?
What happens when you accept a job in your 50s or 60s that doesn't reflect your experience, seniority or capabilities?

Through my ‘next steps’ coaching I speak to quite a few people in their late 50s who find themselves considering jobs that don’t begin to reflect their experience or capabilities.
Not because they’ve decided to slow down or want a less demanding life. They’ve been made redundant, they’re struggling to find another senior position and they still have a mortgage to pay and children to educate.
After 30 or 40 years of building a successful career, it’s not an easy position to find yourself in.
And while taking a less senior job may solve an immediate financial problem, it can create a rather different set of challenges.
When taking a step down in your 50s or 60s isn’t a choice
Much of the discussion about working later in life focuses on people choosing to slow down, escape corporate pressures or pursue other interests.
It’s an attractive proposition. But it rather overlooks those who simply can’t afford to make those choices.
Through the work I do with the organisation Brave Starts, I come across many professionals in their late 50s and beyond who still have substantial financial commitments. Their pensions aren’t sufficient to stop working, and they may need to earn a reasonable income for another ten years.
Yet, as anyone who finds themselves in this position will attest, finding another senior role can become increasingly difficult. Employers may regard us as expensive, overqualified or unlikely to stay for long. I think we all know that although age discrimination is unlawful, age-related assumptions and decisions are really difficult to challenge.
So, what happens when you’re offered a job at a considerably lower salary, with much less responsibility and limited opportunity to exercise the skills you’ve spent decades developing?
Financially, you may have little choice but to accept it. But that doesn’t mean that a lower grade job going to be an easy adjustment.
What happens when your capabilities aren’t being used?
Imagine having spent years leading a team, running your own business or managing substantial budgets, only to find yourself in a job where you’re largely implementing somebody else’s instructions.
You may be reporting to someone considerably younger, with less experience. There’s nothing inherently wrong with that, but it can be frustrating when you feel your knowledge and judgement aren’t being properly recognised.
And there’s a difference between having plenty to do and finding the work intellectually stimulating. I found that having the title of a ‘middle manager’ made me behave like a middle manager.
One of the things we sometimes underestimate is how much satisfaction we derive from being good at what we do. Having our opinions valued, solving difficult problems and feeling that we’re making a worthwhile contribution.
For many professionals, work also provides a significant part of our identity. It’s not simply what we do, but how we see ourselves and, to some extent, how we believe others see them.
Losing a senior position can therefore be difficult enough. Accepting a much more junior role may reinforce our sense of loss.
Of course, there’s also the possibility that we attach too much importance to our professional status. But knowing that intellectually doesn’t necessarily make the adjustment any easier.
From running your own business to working for someone else
I can relate to some of these challenges from my own experience.
Having spent many years running my own business, I subsequently moved into employment within a large organisation.
One of the biggest adjustments was the change in autonomy.
When you’re running your own business, you’re accustomed to making decisions, setting priorities and getting on with things. Of course, you have clients and colleagues to consider, but ultimately, you’re responsible for deciding what happens.
Working within a large organisation is rather different. Decisions involve established procedures, multiple stakeholders and layers of management. Having a good idea isn’t necessarily enough. You also have to persuade other people, navigate internal processes and sometimes accept decisions you wouldn’t have made yourself.
There are obvious advantages to being part of a larger organisation. You have colleagues, resources and the security of a regular salary. And you no longer carry the full responsibility of running a business. I was immensely grateful to have found a job just before the pandemic hit.
Nevertheless, it made me appreciate just how much I’d valued the independence that came with self-employment.
It also raises an interesting question. When we struggle with a less senior job, is it really the loss of status that bothers us, or the loss of autonomy and control over our working lives?
Could a compromise eventually become an opportunity?
It’s easy to tell someone in this situation that they should look for work that’s more fulfilling or better aligned with their interests.
But that’s not especially helpful when the mortgage needs paying.
Taking a job that doesn’t fully stretch you may be the most sensible financial decision available. It provides an income, some security and a continuing connection with the working world.
And perhaps, given time, it might offer some unexpected benefits.
You may discover that you don’t particularly miss the corporate politics of life in the C-suite, demanding clients or responsibility for other people’s performance.
You might enjoy more predictable working hours and greater freedom outside work.
Perhaps the job could become one part of a more varied life, alongside mentoring, consultancy, voluntary work or other activities that provide the intellectual stimulation and sense of achievement you might otherwise be missing.
But I don’t think we should romanticise this.
Someone who has reluctantly accepted a lower-paid job may not be in the mood to appreciate its lifestyle benefits. They may feel frustrated, disappointed and understandably anxious about their financial future.
And there’s no reason why someone in their late 50s or 60s shouldn’t still want the challenge and satisfaction of working at the top of their profession.
What do you really need from work?
One of the questions I often explore in coaching is what people actually want and need from their working lives.
For most of us, work has provided some combination of income, status, autonomy, intellectual stimulation, social connection and a sense of achievement.
But do we necessarily need to get all these things from the same job?
If you’re considering, or have already accepted, a position that doesn’t fully use your capabilities, it may be worth asking yourself:
Is this a temporary financial solution, or could it become a more permanent arrangement?
What do I most miss about my previous work — the salary, seniority, autonomy or intellectual challenge?
Could I find some of that satisfaction elsewhere, without necessarily giving up the financial security of my current job, i.e a side hustle?
And what do I realistically want from the next five or ten years of my working life?
None of these questions will solve the financial pressures or remove the frustration of a difficult job market. But they might help you think more clearly about the choices that remain available.
A different definition of our next chapter
We hear a great deal about the opportunities for reinvention and new beginnings in our later working lives and I coach and write about this.
I believe those opportunities exist. But we should also recognise that not everyone has the financial freedom to pursue them.
For some people, the immediate priority is simply to keep earning enough money to meet their commitments.
And perhaps one of the harder lessons of our later working lives is recognising that our capabilities and experience aren’t always matched by the opportunities available to us.
We may have to make compromises that we wouldn’t have contemplated ten years earlier.
But there’s a difference between compromising on the job we do and compromising on what we still want from life.


